Flair Group
Rated 3 out of 5
It’s a real shame that NYC doesn’t have a consistent, universally recognized hotel classification system to determine which properties truly deserve to call themselves five-star hotels. Because, as it turns out, five stars in a major European city and five stars in New York can be two entirely different galaxies. A few observations from our stay: First, the great mystery of the missing mugs. Our room came equipped with paper cups, but not a single proper mug for tea. Are ceramic mugs considered a theft risk in New York? Or perhaps an extravagant luxury reserved for six-star establishments? A hotel room should feel like a comfortable home away from home. Being able to enjoy a cup of tea from an actual cup seems like a rather modest expectation, especially at this supposed level of hospitality. Second, the elusive slippers. Our room was booked for three guests, yet apparently not one of us qualified for a pair of slippers. Considering that the room was hardly warm and the bathroom floor was particularly cold, this small gesture would have been very welcome. One might assume that keeping guests’ feet warm falls somewhere within the five-star experience. Third, breakfast — an exercise in minimalism. The selection was so limited that one could count the available options on two hands, with fingers to spare. Not even a few tomatoes, cucumbers, or some fresh greens. Apparently, vegetables are another luxury that has yet to make its way into the New York five-star hospitality concept. Finally, a special mention goes to the restaurant staff, for whom I genuinely felt sorry. The dining area felt as though it was approximately 15°C (59°F). While guests could eventually escape to their rooms, the employees had to spend their working hours in what felt more like a refrigerated showroom than a restaurant. The most disappointing part is that none of these complaints concern extravagant luxury. We’re talking about ceramic mugs, slippers, fresh vegetables, and a reasonably warm room. These are not exceptional demands. They are basic comforts. But special thanks to the staff which was super kind and warm. Perhaps it’s time to reconsider what five stars are supposed to represent. Because luxury should be something guests experience, not merely something a hotel awards itself.


